Eat & Drink
Breakfast on Block Island: where the island eats before the boat
Where to actually eat breakfast on Block Island — the bakery line worth joining, the harbor tables, and what to grab before an early ferry.
Where to eat on Block Island, without wasting a meal
There are no chains on Block Island. No drive-throughs, no franchise logos, nothing you've eaten in an airport. What the island has instead is a few dozen kitchens that feed roughly a thousand year-round residents all winter and a hundred times that many people in August — and the gap between the great ones and the fine ones is real money on a short trip.
This section exists to keep you from spending one of your island dinners learning that lesson. Start with the ranked list if you have one night; start with breakfast if you're smart, because breakfast is where this island quietly shows off.
Two things worth knowing before any list: almost everything is seasonal, so an October trip needs a phone call before you build the evening around a specific table. And kitchens here close earlier than you think in the shoulder months — the sunset crowd eats first and the kitchen follows the sunset.
The guides
The best restaurants, ranked
The flagship list — who actually earns your one big dinner out.
Breakfast
Where the island eats before the boats come in.
Seafood
Stuffies, chowder, and the lobster roll question, settled.
Bars & nightlife
Where the night goes after the sun does.
Mudslides
The island’s unofficial drink gets its own page. It earned it.
Ice cream & sweets
The after-beach cone hierarchy.
Fine dining
The handful of white-tablecloth nights the island does well.
The farmers market
What to know before you go, and what sells out first.
Restaurant profiles
Ballard's Beach Resort
Ballard's is the island's beach-day machine: restaurant, beach bar, live music stage, and inn on one stretch of sand next to the ferry. Here's how to do it right.
Dead Eye Dick's
Serving New Harbor since the 1940s: swordfish and lobster over the water, a proper raw bar, and a deck that turns a lunch into an afternoon.
Ernie's Old Harbor Restaurant
Breakfast and lunch on Water Street the old way: pancakes, omelets, harbor views, cash only. Ernie's is where the island actually starts its day.
Kimberly's
Family-owned since 2014 on Ocean Avenue: local seafood, steaks, and pasta done properly, with a patio, a real bar, and the island's go-to catering operation.
The Oar
The Oar hangs over the Great Salt Pond with a deck built for sunset, a serious wine and cocktail list, and a mudslide in permanent contention for the island's best.
The Barn at the Spring House
An open kitchen, a wood-fired grill, and a quiet room at the island's oldest grand hotel — The Barn is Block Island's serious-dinner ticket, ages 12 and up.
The Beachead
Ocean-view porch, garden patio, chowder done right — and the island's back-to-back Most Dog-Friendly champion. The Beachead is Block Island's easy yes.
Winfield's
Chef Billy Chandler's intimate room runs French, Italian, New American, and Asian influences through local ingredients — Block Island's polished dinner, minus the fuss.
Latest from Eat & Drink
Eat & Drink
Block Island bars and nightlife: where the night actually goes
The honest bar map of Block Island: where the night starts, where the bands play, where the mudslides are, and what closes when.
Eat & Drink
Ice cream on Block Island: the after-beach hierarchy
Every proper Block Island beach day ends with a cone. Where the lines form, what's actually worth the wait, and the late-night sugar options in Old Harbor.
Eat & Drink
The Block Island farmers market: when to go, what sells out
The Block Island farmers market in Legion Park is a genuine island tradition. Days, timing, what the regulars grab first, and how to shop it right.
Eat & Drink
The best restaurants on Block Island, ranked by people who eat here all summer
The flagship list: where a Block Island dinner is actually worth the reservation, from beach-sand lobster rolls to the wood-fired room on the hill.
Eat & Drink
Fine dining on Block Island: the short list that earns the linen
Block Island does white-tablecloth sparingly and well. The Barn's wood-fired room, Winfield's global menu, and the hotel dining rooms worth dressing for.
Good questions
- What food is Block Island known for?
- Seafood that came off a boat you can see from your table: lobster rolls, stuffies (stuffed quahogs), clam chowder, and oysters. The island’s unofficial drink is the mudslide — several bars claim the best one, and we keep score.
- Do Block Island restaurants take reservations?
- The sit-down places mostly do, and on July and August weekends you want one. Plenty of the best meals here are counter-service, though — no reservation required, just a tolerance for a line that moves.
- Are restaurants open year-round?
- A handful are; most close between mid-October and Memorial Day. If you visit off-season, check hours before you build a day around a specific kitchen.